A Legal Analysis

The USA PATRIOT Act passed in the wake of the September 11 terrorist
attacks. It flows from a consultation draft circulated by the Department of Justice,
to which Congress made substantial modifications and additions. The stated purpose
of the Act is to enable law enforcement officials to track down and punish those
responsible for the attacks and to protect against any similar attacks.
The Act grants federal officials greater powers to trace and intercept terrorists’
communications both for law enforcement and foreign intelligence purposes. It
reenforces federal anti-money laundering laws and regulations in an effort to deny
terrorists the resources necessary for future attacks. It tightens our immigration laws
to close our borders to foreign terrorists and to expel those among us. Finally, it
creates a few new federal crimes, such as the one outlawing terrorists’ attacks on
mass transit; increases the penalties for many others; and institutes several procedural
changes, such as a longer statute of limitations for crimes of terrorism.
Critics have suggested that it may go too far. The authority to monitor e-mail
traffic, to share grand jury information with intelligence and immigration officers, to
confiscate property, and to impose new book-keeping requirements on financial
institutions, are among the features troubling to some.
The Act itself responds to some of these reservations. Many of the wiretapping
and foreign intelligence amendments sunset on December 31, 2005. The Act creates
judicial safeguards for e-mail monitoring and grand jury disclosures; recognizes
innocent owner defenses to forfeiture; and entrusts enhanced anti-money laundering
powers to those regulatory authorities whose concerns include the well being of our
financial institutions.
This report, stripped of its citations and footnotes, is available in an abbreviated
form as The USA PATRIOT Act: A Sketch, CRS REP.NO. RS21203. In addition,
much of the information contained here may also be found under a different
arrangement in a report entitled, Terrorism: Section by Section Analysis of the USA
PATRIOT Act, CRS REP.NO. RL31200 (Dec. 10, 2001). A wider array of terrorism-
related analysis appears on the CRS terrorism electronic briefing book page.